calorap99 shares a challenging C# inheritance puzzle, inviting readers to predict the console output of a code snippet involving constructors and method overriding.

Summary

In this post, calorap99 presents a C# programming puzzle focused on class inheritance, constructor behavior, and virtual methods. The central challenge is to guess the console output for a specific code sample.

The Code

public class Program {
    public static void Main() {
        BaseClass result = new DerivedClass();
        Console.WriteLine(result.Value);
    }
}

public class BaseClass {
    public string Value;
    public BaseClass() {
        Value = Func();
    }
    public virtual string Func() {
        return "Base Function";
    }
}

public class DerivedClass : BaseClass {
    public DerivedClass() : base() { }
    public override string Func() {
        return "Overridden Function";
    }
}

Analysis

  • The Main method instantiates a DerivedClass, storing it in a BaseClass reference.
  • The BaseClass constructor assigns Value by calling the Func() method.
  • Func() is a virtual method, and DerivedClass overrides it.
  • In C#, when a base class constructor is running and the derived class overrides a virtual method, the overridden method in the derived class is called, even before the derived constructor executes.

Expected Console Output

  • Because the BaseClass constructor sets Value to the result of Func(), and Func() is overridden in DerivedClass, the statement

    Value = Func();

    during base construction will call DerivedClass.Func(), returning “Overridden Function”.

  • Therefore, the output of Console.WriteLine(result.Value); will be: Overridden Function

Key Takeaways

  • Calling virtual methods in a base class constructor can lead to overridden method execution, even though the derived object is not fully constructed.
  • This C# behavior is important for developers to understand, as it may cause unexpected results or subtle bugs.

Learning Points

  • Avoid calling virtual methods in constructors unless you are aware of the complexity and risks involved.
  • Understanding how inheritance and constructor execution order interact helps write more predictable and robust object-oriented code.

This post appeared first on “Reddit CSharp”. Read the entire article here